Effects of Different Toothpastes Against Erosive Tooth Wear of Enamel and Dentine in Vitro

Abstract

Background The increase in the prevalence of erosion lesions worldwide has led researchers to develop effective toothpastes with different ingredients to prevent erosion that can protect the tooth surface against acid attacks. There remains a lack of consensus in the literature regarding which toothpaste formulation exhibits the most effective preventive action against erosive tooth wear, highlighting the necessity for further investigation in this field. This study aimed to evaluate the preventive effect of brushing with toothpastes with different ingredients on enamel and dentine erosion. Methods The crowns and roots of ninety recently extracted bovine incisors were seperated and ground flat to obtain enamel and dentine surfaces. The obtained specimens were then divided into six groups: Curaprox Enzycal Zero Flouride (fluoride-free), Colgate Total 12 (1450 ppm NaF), Splat Biocalcium (fluoride-free and Nano-HAP), Colgate ProRelief (1450 ppm NaF and arginine), Sensodyne Repair and Protection (1450 ppm NaF and novamin), Opalescence Whitening (1100 ppm NaF). The specimens were immersed in a demineralizing solution for 2 min and in an artificial saliva for 60 min 4 times a day for 5 days. Brushing was performed with the aid of a charged toothbrush immediately after the first and last erosive attacks. Initial and final surface roughness (at the end of fifth day) were measured using a 3D profilometer. The Wilcoxon test was used to compare initial and final roughness values (p < 0.05). Results Opalescence Whitening and Curaprox Enzycal Zero Fluoride significantly increased both enamel and dentine surface roughness compared to baseline, demonstrating rougher surfaces than all other groups except Colgate ProRelief (p < 0.001). Sensodyne Repair and Protection and Colgate Total 12 resulted in the smoothest enamel and dentine surfaces, respectively. The increase in surface roughness was significantly higher for enamel samples compared to dentine samples in the Opalescence Whitening group (p < 0.001). Conclusions Whitening toothpastes may exacerbate dental erosion by increasing surface roughness. The protective properties of fluoride-free toothpastes vary depending on their active ingredient.